Call us: 555-555-5555

Diary 7

Diary  7 - a few decorative flourishes.


Tagin are the little crownlets that make much of the difference between what is merely Hebrew block lettering and what one sees in the holy texts (K’tav Ashurit). No-one quite knows what these embellishments really mean (though I have developed some theories over time) and the Rambam argues that their absence does not invalidate the writing as the core of the letter form is there. However, the halachah dictates that certain letters should have these decorative flourishes, which the sofer creates by drawing ink upwards from the roof of the letter with the very thin tip of the quill (or down from little blobs towards the roof of the letter).

The famous mnemonic is Sha’atnez Gats showing the letters that have three tagin. Others only have one and some have none at all.

One of the readers of my off-line articles questioned why the upside-down kuzo phrase on the reverse of my first m'zuzah (see diary 3) had tagin as she had not seen this before. In fact the omission of the entire phrase itself would not make the m'zuzah pasul (invalid) and having checked on-line with a sofer in Israel, there is no halachic statement as to whether there should be tagin or not. His view is that there normally are - though many small m'zuzot don’t have - indeed many of these have no, or very poorly formed tagin in the text.

Tagin perhaps represent the scribes best chance of individual expression and shows that despite the vast amount of rules and regulations the individualism of the scribe can shine through. I have used this to good effect in my m'gillot where when there are two or three letters with tagin together you can create a sort of bridge or rainbow effect. Considerable creative license can be seen with the splayed or dotted tagin that can be seen below, though some sofrim would frown on such a thing.
Below - (Top) an extract from Lishkat Hasofer  explaining the secret of Sha’atnez Gats- that they contain the names of three demons, Satan, Ez and Gats, and the tagin are daggers that protect us from them!  (Middle) a bridging effect.  and a fantastic splayed lamed on the word  hamelech (the king) from a  m'gillah belonging to a synagogue in Edgware. Much freedom is allowed when working on a m'gillah than with other works. Photos © Mordechai Pinchas. (Bottom) From an 18th century polish Torah copied by my teachers' teacher Eric Ray z"l. The splayed tagin are very unusual and are attempts by Kabbalist scribes to increase the  Sh'chinah (Divine Presence) in the work. Note the  peh m'lufefet (spiral  peh) too. Also an example gleaned from the internet (not sure of source - please let me know if you know it) with some crazy firework tagin and tails.
The tagin themselves are said to originate directly from Sinai, as when Moses ascended the mountain he found God engaged in affixing them to the letters. When asked why, God replies that a man will arise - Rabbi Akiva - who will derive from each tag heaps and heaps of laws. Moses asks to see him and is transported to the future to Akiva’s classroom where he is unable to understand a thing and is somewhat disturbed to learn about Akiva’s painful end as a matyr. (Talmud M'nachot 29b).

Can one really write a whole article on a few decorative flourishes? Well, you can, and you just read it!

Mordechai Pinchas

Postscript:
Looking back on this diary (which I guess was a blog before there were blogs) I can see the start of a lifelong fascination with tagin and other peculiarities with letter forms (otiyot m'shunot) and this particular area became a major source of study for particularly around  the special work Sefer Tagin. I eventually developed these ideas further in my books Tikkun M'gillat Hashoah, The Dot on the Ot, Megillat B'ney Chashmonay, The Torah in the Wardrobe, and Sefer Binsoa. I've collected numerous examples, made interesting manuscript discoveries and have been working on various papers on the topic.Not only can you write an article on tagin, you can write several books on it! Tagin have become very important to me.

GO TO DIARY 8
Share by: